What were you thinking
Is this a Question or a Statement?
For some reason I here those words and think back to my childhood. It makes me think of times when I was in trouble and getting scolded by my mother for something that I had done that was probably (definitely) not the brightest thing to do. But what if we as educators took that phrase and used it on a regular basis in our classrooms? Not for students that are misbehaving, but what if we asked this question in a positive educational context? What would happen to the learning in our classrooms?
How often do we ask our students the following:
"What were you thinking when... You worked through that problem?"
You solved that equation?"
You composed this essay?"
You created this project?"
You played that guitar piece?"
You wrote this blog post?"
Is it the fact that the phrase "what were you thinking" has such a negative picture in our minds that we don't want to use it in our classrooms? I know that I didn't ask these questions nearly enough in my own classroom. Why didn't I let my students learn out loud? Is it that fact that we don't know where the conversation could go and we are afraid to get off track? I know that I was always worried about making sure that I got through all the content that need to get covered, and although I wanted to pursue other topics, timing and pacing (I felt) didn't allow. But imagine what could have been DISCOVERED if I had! Instead of worrying about covering the content, what would have happened if I let the content reveal itself through the questioning of the students.
During our Instructional Rounds last week one of the areas of focus that was discovered was improving questioning. Questioning Strategies that would and could lead to further and deeper discussions.
Imagine some of the conversations, discussions and LEARNING that would happen in our classrooms if we simply asked, "What were you thinking?"